2. Does a Keto Diet increase the risk of DKA?

2. Does a Keto Diet increase the Risk of DKA?

This is probably the most understandable concern about ketogenic diets and type 1 diabetes. We are taught from diagnosis to be wary of ketones because ketones can accompany diabetic ketoacidosis (DKA). So why would anyone deliberately follow a diet that produces them?
THE SHORT ANSWER
Because nutritional ketosis and diabetic ketoacidosis are different metabolic states.

The important difference is insulin

When carbohydrate availability is reduced, the body increases its use of fat. The liver converts some fatty acids into ketone bodies, which can be used for energy by tissues including the muscles, heart and brain.

This is nutritional ketosis.

Ketone production is strongly influenced by insulin. Insulin suppresses fat release and ketone production; lower insulin permits more fat metabolism. In nutritional ketosis, insulin is still present and ketone production remains regulated.

DKA is very different.

In DKA there is insufficient insulin for the body’s needs. Glucose rises, fat metabolism becomes uncontrolled and ketones can accumulate to dangerous levels, producing acidosis, dehydration and potentially a life-threatening emergency.

So the presence of ketones alone doesn’t define DKA.

The metabolic context matters.

Keto does not mean stopping insulin

This is particularly important for someone encountering Type1Keto for the first time.

People with type 1 diabetes require insulin whether they eat 20 grams or 200 grams of carbohydrate.

A ketogenic diet doesn’t protect against DKA either. Illness, missed insulin, pump failure or another situation producing insufficient insulin can still cause DKA.

That means the familiar safety principles remain important: take your insulin, have access to blood ketone testing, know your sick-day plan and seek appropriate medical help when glucose, ketones or symptoms suggest that something is wrong.

The Type1Keto survey found that 75% of respondents who reported their nutritional-ketosis readings were between 0.5 and 1.5 mmol/L. This is an interesting real-world observation, although an online survey should not be treated as a clinical trial.

Same word, different situation

Much of the confusion comes from the word ketone appearing in both conditions.

The important question for someone with type 1 diabetes is whether ketone production is occurring in a regulated environment with sufficient insulin, or because insulin has become dangerously deficient.

Understanding that distinction helps remove some of the fear surrounding nutritional ketosis without underestimating the seriousness of DKA.

THE LARGER PRINCIPLE
Ketones are fuel molecules
The important question for someone with type 1 diabetes is whether ketone production is occurring in a regulated environment with sufficient insulin, or because insulin has become dangerously deficient.

The difference between ketosis and DKA is explored in more detail in Shifting Gears.

"
So the presence of ketones alone doesn't define DKA.
The metabolic context matters.

START YOUR JOURNEY

Discover a new way of thinking about insulin, nutrition, and Type 1 diabetes.