1. Is It Safe to Reduce Carbohydrates?

1. Is It Safe to Reduce Carbohydrates?

If you live with type 1 diabetes, reducing carbohydrate can sound counterintuitive. After all, doesn’t the body need glucose? Yes, it does. But needing glucose is not the same as needing to eat large amounts of carbohydrate.
THE SHORT ANSWER
Yes. When done thoughtfully, reducing carbohydrate can be safe for people with type 1 diabetes. The body can use glucose, fatty acids and ketones for energy, and lower carbohydrate intake often means lower mealtime insulin. Insulin, however, remains essential.

Glucose is needed, but not only from carbohydrates

Glucose is an important fuel, and some cells depend upon it. However, the body stores glucose as glycogen and can also make glucose when required through gluconeogenesis. When carbohydrate availability falls, it can increasingly use fatty acids and ketones for energy.

Why aim for nutritional ketosis?

The Type1Keto approach deliberately restricts carbohydrate sufficiently to encourage nutritional ketosis. This isn’t about depriving the body of fuel. It is about increasing access to different fuels.

Rather than relying predominantly on dietary carbohydrate, the body can use glucose, fatty acids and ketones according to circumstances. I call this multifuelling.

For someone with type 1 diabetes, reducing carbohydrate has another important consequence: less carbohydrate generally means less mealtime insulin.

The Law of Small Numbers

This brings us to Dr Richard Bernstein’s Law of Small Numbers.

Neither food absorption nor injected insulin is perfectly predictable. A meal requiring eight units of insulin leaves considerably more room for a large dosing error than one requiring one or two units. Smaller glucose and insulin inputs tend to produce smaller potential errors.

Insulin remains essential

Nutritional ketosis does not mean stopping insulin.

People with type 1 diabetes require insulin regardless of how little carbohydrate they eat. Insulin requirements can change substantially when carbohydrate is reduced, so insulin needs to be adjusted appropriately.

The objective isn’t minimum insulin. It is Optimised Insulin: as much insulin as needed, as little as possible.

Smaller inputs. Smaller potential errors.

Reducing the size of both carbohydrate and insulin inputs can reduce the size of the potential variation when either food absorption or insulin action doesn’t behave exactly as expected.

A whole-body approach

My preference is a varied, nutrient-dense ketogenic diet because nutritional ketosis supports multifuelling while reducing the glucose and insulin inputs I have to manage.

But nutrition isn’t the only influence on insulin. Activity, mindset, environment and circadian rhythms can all alter insulin sensitivity and requirements. Together with nutrition, these form what I call the Five Foundations of Health.

THE LARGER PRINCIPLE
It isn’t simply “eat fewer carbs”.
It is to understand the factors influencing insulin and supply the amount the body actually needs.

That wider idea of Optimised Insulin is explored in more detail in Shifting Gears.

"

The objective isn’t minimum insulin.

It is Optimised Insulin:
as much as needed,
as little as possible.

START YOUR JOURNEY

Discover a new way of thinking about insulin, nutrition, and Type 1 diabetes.